search_button_sml
 
     
 
 Education  
 Related Topics
 Community Strength
 Education
 Family Life
 Health
 Indigenous Affairs
 Welfare State
   

Student photo

   
 
More than 3 in 10 Australian families now pay to send their children to a private school, even though they are also paying for state schools through their taxes. These parents are not necessarily wealthy – many earn around the average income, and sometimes much less – but they are prepared to pay fees to get two things the government system does not give them: choice and accountability.

The government school system is remarkably secretive. Under the influence of the teacher unions, schools in most states still refuse to release the information parents need in order to compare performances across schools. The system is also very centralized – head teachers cannot decide on hiring and firing of staff, for example, but must accept the people they are sent. Nor are they allowed to take on teachers in subjects where there are shortages and train them on the job. All this could and should be changed.

The biggest reform, however, would be to extend school choice to all parents. There are various ways this could be done – through charter schools, for example, or by means of education vouchers – but the best strategy would be to give all parents education tax credits so they can pay their own money to buy the schooling they think best suits the needs of their own children.

Higher education, too, needs reforming. The current system of quotas and price controls provides universities with neither the incentives nor the capacity to offer high quality, professionally delivered higher education. Universities should be free to decide for themselves how many students to take and what fees to charge. They should also be free to bundle their services and charge for them accordingly (some might then offer a basic, no frills package while others offer a full campus experience).

Key questions:

  • What explains the differential performance of state and privately-run schools, and why do girls tend to perform better than boys in secondary education?

  • What are the benefits of parental choice in schooling, and what policies enhance the ability of schools to compete effectively in an education market?
  • How should higher education be funded to ensure Australian universities reach world standards and graduates get the courses they want?

Jennifer Buckingham Jennifer Buckingham is a Research Fellow with the Social Foundations programme at The Centre for Independent Studies. Jennifer returned to CIS in May 2005 after a year as schools editor at The Australian newspaper.

Jennifer has published policy monographs on school choice, boys’ education and school performance reporting and edited the CIS’ State of the Nation series. She is also the author of Boy Troubles (2000), Families, Freedom and Education (2001) and Schools in the Spotlight (2003).

She has been at the forefront of debate on education matters, with more than a hundred articles in major newspapers and regular radio appearances.

 
 
 

 

 
 

Copyright The Centre for Independent Studies
Please contact The Centre for Independent Studies Limited (cis@cis.org.au) for permission to reprint material.