This past weekend, just for Mother’s Day, there was a further relaxation; but otherwise, the 50 kilometres limits remain.
No reasons were given in either policy or medical terms as to why 50 kilometres. Why not 55 kilometres or just 10 kilometres? The 50 kilometres rule is inexplicable.
That means from Brisbane CBD, you could only drive as far north as Caboolture, as far west as Ipswich and south just to Logan.
Under the 50 kilometres limit you cannot travel from Brisbane north to the Sunshine Coast (90 kilometres), south to the Gold Coast (80 kilometres) or west to the garden city of Toowoomba (125 kilometres).
The real and possibly sensible aim of the 50 kilometres rule, though not articulated by the Queensland government, may have been to limit the number of Brisbane people going to the Sunshine Coast or the Gold Coast so as to avoid traffic jams as often occurs during holiday periods.
Nevertheless, the result was to further punish these tourism regions already pulverized by Queensland’s border controls, curtailed international travel, and the previous other travel restrictions that began during Easter and included banning travel even to your own holiday home (by the way, in Victoria you could).
Of course, the other problem with the 50 kilometres rule is that it is not fair to those in regional Queensland.
Queensland is not only a big place, but also a highly decentralised one. If you live in a regional area (where there are no virus cases), travelling a few hundred kilometres for a day out is not unusual. If you reside in a small country community, the next large regional centre is often far more than 50 kilometres.
Also, the unintended adverse effects of the 50km restrictions last weekend — with so few destinations near Brisbane to visit — were congestion, pollution, traffic jams, long queues at coffee shops and over-crowding on our previously abandoned parks and beaches. Exactly what the medical advice has been warning against.
For Mother’s Day, the new travel rules were just as inane. On Sunday we could travel more than 50 kilometres, but once at the destination we were advised “you cannot go to the beach, go shopping or go out in that community. You can visit the home and then return to your own home.” So, it is a case of “Hi Mum” and then “Goodbye – sorry can’t stay”. Within the 50 kilometres radius you can go to the beach, outside the 50 kilometres radius you can’t!
Queenslanders remain on a tight leash of travel restrictions that have neither a sound basis of policy nor any explained medical evidence.
Scott Prasser is a Senior Fellow at the Centre for Independent Studies.