A House Divided: The AFRB and China's Subnational Diplomacy in Australia

Salvatore Babones
12 November 2020 | AP17
A House Divided: The AFRB and China's Subnational Diplomacy in Australia

This paper examines China’s subnational diplomacy in Australia and the suitability of Australia’s Foreign Relations Bill (AFRB) as a tool for countering it. The AFRB is designed to help the Commonwealth keep tabs on international diplomacy involving Australian states, territories, local governments, and public universities. The obvious target of the bill is China, which has systematically circumvented traditional international diplomacy by building relationships directly with states and territories. The AFRB would give the foreign minister the authority to abrogate agreements like Victoria’s deal to join China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and require federal pre-approval for any similar moves in the future. It would also allow the Commonwealth to review and potentially cancel Australian universities’ 13 China-sponsored Confucius Institutes. As written, however, the AFRB is bureaucratically heavy-handed and would continue to allow subnational diplomacy to be conducted in the shadows, away from public scrutiny. It will do more to help the Commonwealth avoid political embarrassment than to quash untoward foreign influence over Australian subnational governments and public universities. A better approach to managing foreign influence and interference would be to expose subnational foreign government agreements to proper public oversight through much higher levels of mandatory public disclosure.

Latest Publications

The End of Monetary Policy?
Warren Hogan
29 October 2020 | AP16

Monetary policy is not the answer to our economic problems; and central bank actions could be making matters worse. This paper outlines that monetary policy in most advanced economies is suffering from overreach and has been for much of the past decade. Many of the problems economies face cannot be solved by easy money. They are structural, so can only…

READ MORE
Parents’ perspectives on home-based learning in the covid-19 pandemic
Glenn Fahey, Blaise Joseph
30 September 2020 | AP15

School closures during the covid-19 pandemic temporarily shifted schooling from the classroom to the home. This paper provides an insight into parents’ perspectives of this experience of home-based learning. The research shows parents have a wide range of views on how, how often, and how well schooling was carried out. Parents also differ on how they say their child progressed…

READ MORE
RATIONALISING REGULATION: Helping the economy recover from the corona crisis
Gene Tunny, Ben Scott
23 September 2020 | AP14

Australia’s anachronistic, inconsistent, and excessive regulatory landscape is an area of immense potential for growth-enhancing economic reforms. The regulatory constraints outlined in this paper are impeding business growth and their removal or adjustment would yield large economic benefits. The relaxation of a range of restrictions to respond to the pandemic—e.g. around supermarket delivery times and the availability of liquor for…

READ MORE
Cancelled! How ideological cleansing threatens Australia
Peter Kurti
17 August 2020 | AP13

‘Cancel culture’ campaigns in Australia are intended to erase elements of our history and to deny the record of those who helped found this country. The impulse to impose a revised interpretation of the past poses a danger that threatens to corrode civility, destroy civic trust, and fuel community discord. The drive to eradicate offensive words, images, and opinions from…

READ MORE
Industrial Relations in a Post-COVID World
Judith Sloan
13 August 2020 | AP12

The economic shocks of COVID-19 and the associated government responses have rendered aspects of our industrial relations regulations unworkable and/or perverse. While the system of regulation was initially a federated role in which the states played significant roles, the federal jurisdiction is now dominant. Apart from Western Australia, all other states have referred their industrial relations powers to the Commonwealth.…

READ MORE