Products – The Centre for Independent Studies

Criminalising Hate Speech: Australia’s crusade against vilification

Monica Wilkie
18 September 2019 | AP6
Criminalising Hate Speech: Australia’s crusade against vilification

In Australia, there are a range of criminal and civil vilification laws that exist to provide recourse for victims of vilification. However, most states and territories are currently reviewing their vilification laws as there is the belief they inadequately protect minorities.

In the wake of a reported rise in racial and sectarian violence, many argue vilification laws need to be expanded to prevent violence. These claims are misguided and will result in unacceptable speech restrictions.

To protect minorities and free speech, criminal vilification laws need to set an appropriately high threshold of incitement or threats of violence. Any amendments to vilification laws should be done at the state and territory level and should adopt the model established in, the Crimes Amendment (Publicly Threatening and Inciting Violence) Bill 2018, that NSW introduced.

This paper also examines the history of how Australia’s vilification laws were formed focusing on both domestic and international changes towards laws restricting speech.

Latest Publications

Township Leasing and the Democratisation of Opportunity
Peter Gregory
02 December 2021 | AP30

Township leasing was a significant 2006 reform to the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (ALRA). It gave Traditional Owners the right to issue leases and licenses for economic activity over a given township on ALRA land, subject to the consent of the relevant Land Council. This paper discusses township leasing from an institutional economics perspective. It argues that…

READ MORE
Failing to teach the teacher: An analysis of mathematics Initial Teacher Education
Glenn Fahey, Jordan O’Sullivan, Jared Bussell
25 November 2021 | AP29

Policymakers have increasingly looked to improvements in Initial Teacher Education (ITE) as key to overcoming declining education outcomes. The analysis in this paper validates this concern and places a specific lens on ITE for beginning mathematics teachers. Despite clear evidence of the efficacy of explicit instruction, it is not practiced consistently and regularly in Australia’s mathematics classrooms. The analysis shows…

READ MORE
Between Geography and History: Delhi and Canberra in Indo-Pacific Security
C. Raja Mohan
11 November 2021 | AP28

The relationship between Delhi and Canberra has grown rapidly in recent years, underpinned by a convergence of security interests in the new Indo-Pacific geography and complemented by their membership of the revived Quad that includes Japan and the United States. This has helped overcome the traditional estrangement between India and Australia that dates back to the onset of the Cold…

READ MORE
Time to ‘step up’ the tempo: Australia’s answer to Beijing in Papua New Guinea
Sean Jacobs
21 October 2021 | AP27

Australia’s ‘step up’ in the Pacific is now five years old and needs a more ‘up tempo’ approach, particularly in Papua New Guinea (PNG) where China’s influence has grown significantly – from building PNG’s national data centre to backing a Chinese company’s proposal for a new fisheries facility just kilometres from Australia’s northernmost border in the Torres Strait. At times,…

READ MORE
Xi Dreams of 100 More Glorious Years for the Party: Might China Awake?
Rowan Callick
16 September 2021 | AP26

The Chinese Communist Party is at the peak of its power as it enters its second century. This paper examines its evolution over the last 100 years, before turning to its centenary celebrations in July 2021 with Xi Jinping at the helm. It then focuses on potential paths ahead, arguing that the Party’s grip on history and ideology will be…

READ MORE