Lands of Shame: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ‘Homelands’ in Transition

Helen Hughes
30 June 2007 | SP09
Lands of Shame: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ‘Homelands’ in Transition

Some 90,000 of Australia’s 500,000 Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders live appallingly deprived lives in ‘homelands’ throughout remote Australia.  Although these ‘homelands’ were created with the best of intentions, they have not only failed to provide a living for Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders, but they have stultified the development of Indigenous culture so that alcoholism and violence demean and destroy many lives.

In this groundbreaking book, Professor Helen Hughes details the disgraceful state of these Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander so-called ‘homelands’, covering demographic trends, the state of security, policing and the law, land ownership, communal enterprises, the lack of education and health, derelict housing and miserable government. The book looks at Territory/State and Commonwealth policies and suggests where policies should be headed to fix these running sores.

The release of the book coincides with the 40th anniversary of the 1967 referendum that gave removed two references in the Australian Constitution that discriminated against Indigenous people The ‘homelands’ policies introduced in the 1970s, however, continued to treat Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders as being different from other Australians.

Hughes writes, ‘It is not true that various policies have been tried and have failed. Policies have always been discriminatory, treating Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders differently from other Australians.’

‘Sadly, the most damaging discrimination in Australia’s history has been the exceptionalism of the last 30 years that was intended to make up for past mistreatment. It has widened the gap between Indigenous and mainstream Australians in critical respects.’




Latest Publications

Where Your Tax Dollars Go
Robert Carling
09 July 2014 | SP14

Taxation is imposed through the coercive power of the state. Politicians often speak of “asking” taxpayers to pay more of this or that tax, but in reality they can and do tell citizens what to pay. It is vital to the functioning of democracy that voters know what their taxes are paying for. Often they don’t, because the information is…

Budget 2014-15: Fiscal responsibility or savage cuts?
Alexander Philipatos, Benjamin Herscovitch, Helen Andrews, Jennifer Buckingham, Matthew Taylor, Robert Carling, Simon Cowan, Stephen Kirchner, Steven Schwartz, Trisha Jha
16 May 2014 | SP13

The CIS analyses the Abbott government’s crucial first budget, including significant changes in the key policy areas of health, tax measures, welfare and education.        

When Prophecy Fails
Peter Saunders
09 September 2011 | SP12

In their 2009 book, The Spirit Level, Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett argued for the ‘benefits’ of income redistribution. Although enthusiastically welcomed by the left, CIS Senior Fellow Peter Sanders showed in his critique Beware False Prophets that much of The Spirit Level’s evidence linking equality with wellbeing was flawed, its analysis is misleading, and its statistics invalid. Saunders’s book…

No Quick Fix: Three Essays on the Future of the Australian Hospital System
Jeremy Sammut
21 October 2010 | SP11

Reestablishing local hospital boards is wrongly described as a ‘quick fix’ for the problems in the Australian public hospital system. The trilogy of essays in this collection describes the negative impact the bureaucratisation of the system has had on staff and patients in the last 30 years. The authors argue that unless accountable pro bono boards are put back in…

Schools of Thought: A Collection of Articles on Education
Jennifer Buckingham
01 July 2009 | SP10

Over the last decade, schools policy in Australia has undergone significant changes.  Jennifer Buckingham has been a significant contributor to the public debate surrounding these changes, drawing on research and reason to argue for reforms to improve quality and equity in education. This collection of opinion articles published in major newspapers since 2000 provides a sample of Buckingham’s work.  …