Between Two Worlds. Australian Foreign Policy Responses to New and Old Security Dilemmas

David Martin Jones
23 October 2005 | OP97
Between Two Worlds.  Australian Foreign Policy Responses to New and Old Security Dilemmas

Australian foreign policy is entering an era of complexity and strategic uncertainty.  Globalisation has spawned the rise of new threats in the form of transnational crime syndicates smuggling drugs, people and weapons together with transnational terrorists specialising in asymmetric warfare.  At the same time the world is beginning to resemble a traditional geopolitical chessboard with regional power centres forming in Europe and Asia that ultimately seek to balance American hegemony.  The international system thus appears split between a 20th century paradigm centred on the nation-state and a 21st century world in which sub-state and trans-state actors take on increasing importance.  Globalisation has connected these two worlds through ease of travel, communications and financial flows, but it has not integrated them.

The split is particularly pronounced in the Asia Pacific region, and requires a foreign policy flexibility that can address both old and new security dilemmas simultaneously.  This paper analyses the nature of these dilemmas and the foreign policy traditions that shape Australia’s response to them.  The authors argue that Australian strategic thinking remains muddled in some quarters by a utopian internationalist and/or regionalist approach that has been reinvigorated by the inaugural East Asian Summit in December 2005.  But multilateralism alone cannot do the work of maintaining a stable balance of power in East Asia whilst transnational threats in South East Asia are likely to respond better to a reassertion of sovereignty at home and new partnerships and alliances abroad.  Australian foreign policymakers should take their cues from Hobbes and Machiavelli rather than Kant.



Buy Hardcopy
Latest Publications

Taking Back Control: Restoring Universalism in the Age of Identity Politics
Amanda Stoker
16 April 2019 | OP170

It can feel safer avoiding conversations on social issues that can be landmines at the best of times. But the longer those who believe in freedom and responsibility sit on the sidelines, the longer we give free rein for others to shape the debate. Where we can start to shift debate is on the role of government and other institutions…

Why God is Good for You
Greg Sheridan
28 November 2018 | OP169

Conversation with The Australian’s Foreign Editor Greg Sheridan and CIS senior research fellow Peter Kurti on the intellectual, historical and cultural case for belief in God. Australia and many parts of the West are losing faith in God. And yet the Judeo-Christian tradition has created and underpinned the moral and legal fabric of Western Civilisation. Where the moral certainties that underpin Australia’s institutions and laws are…

Have We All Gone Mad? The Snowflake Epidemic
Steven Schwartz, Lindsay Shepherd, Claire Lehmann, Tiffany Jenkins
22 November 2018 | OP168

University campuses throughout the West are in the grip of a troubling social phenomenon, now in danger of spreading beyond the ivy walls. Once bastions of intellectual rigour and freedom of thought, universities have become closed-minded and self-censoring, pandering to what appear from the outside to be ridiculously heightened sensitivities and undeserved entitlement. Safe spaces, trigger warnings and counselling on…

Conflict vs Mistake: Academic cultures and explanatory conflict
Claire Lehmann
11 September 2018 | OP167

The 2018 Helen Hughes Lecture explains why and how universities are fuelling the corrosive identity politics phenomena that is sweeping western countries. With a mix of erudition and common sense, Claire Lehmann — the founder and editor-in-chief of renowned online magazine Quillette — unpacks complicated academic theories and draws laser-sharp attention to the impact these theories have on contemporary society…

John Howard: A Conversation on Culture
John Howard, Tom Switzer, Jeremy Sammut
26 July 2018 | OP166

Based on the remarks made by former Prime Minister John Howard at the launch of  The Centre for Independent Studies’ new Culture, Prosperity and Civil Society Program at the CIS’s Sydney office in July 2018 This  hour long ‘Conversation About Culture’ ranged over many of the important topics that are at the heart of contemporary social, economic and political debates…