Myth vs Reality: The case against increasing Capital Gains Tax

Robert Carling
05 March 2019 | PP18
Myth vs Reality: The case against increasing Capital Gains Tax

Australia’s capital gains tax (CGT) policy has been largely settled for almost 20 years. However, it has come under renewed scrutiny as a result of the Australian Labor Party’s federal election platform proposal to halve the 50% CGT discount and thereby effectively increase the tax by 50%.

If the objective of reforming the CGT is to do no more than compensate for inflation, no flat percentage discount will achieve it other than by chance; and a 25% discount will not be sufficient to achieve it in many cases. Even the 50% discount fails to achieve it if the rate of nominal capital gain on an asset is less than twice the rate of inflation.

Inflation compensation would be better achieved by returning to the cost base indexation system that applied up to 1999.

However, there are many justifications for a CGT discount other than compensating for inflation, and those reasons — such as the effect on incentives to invest — are being overlooked in the current debate. A flat percentage discount is a simple design and should be thought of as a rough and approximate way to recognise all the reasons for a concessional CGT.

Rather than halve the discount, it would be better to either:

  • Retain the 50% discount, OR
  • Restore cost base indexation and apply a small discount (say 10 – 20%) to real gains.
Latest Publications

Budget 2019: Why the long-term tax cuts should be fast-tracked
John Humphreys
04 April 2019 | PP19

The centrepiece of the 2019/20 budget was a proposed doubling of the income tax cuts that were legislated last year. Both the short-run LMITO change and the long-run tax cuts will reduce tax, but the two approaches are fundamentally different. These differences are important, but they are hidden by the superficial nature of the tax debate in Australia. To differentiate…

READ MORE
Does Western Civilisation Have a Future?
Wolfgang Kasper
19 February 2019 | PP17

The question, whether our civilisation has a future, will sound preposterous to many. Has Western civilisation not overcome many a crisis in its thousand-year history? Has it not — in its modern incarnation of individual freedom, the capitalist market economy and democratic control of government predation — flourished since 1945? Has the West not reached unheard-of levels of longevity, material…

READ MORE
Dividend Franking Credit Refunds: principle vs revenue
Robert Carling
12 February 2019 | PP16

Under Australia’s dividend imputation system of taxation, since 2000 taxpayers whose franking credits exceed their tax liability have been paid a cash refund of the excess. The Labor opposition’s policy is to continue with the imputation system but to abolish cash refunds of excess franking credits, subject to a carve-out for some age pensioners. This has aroused a storm of…

READ MORE
Reading Recovery: A Failed Investment
Jennifer Buckingham
07 February 2019 | PP15

Reading Recovery is an early intervention program for students in Year 1 who are having difficulty learning to read. It is widely used in Australia, the USA, Canada, England, Ireland, France and Denmark. It is endorsed by many leading educators and teacher professional organisations. Yet numerous studies of Reading Recovery have provided no sound evidence that it has sustained positive…

READ MORE
I, Mechanical Pencil: Why a socialist economy can never work
Steven Kates
06 February 2019 | PP14

Socialism brings poverty and oppression. The ignorance of so many as to why only a market economy is capable of bringing prosperity and political freedom is a major problem. Too many believe a socialist utopia can be achieved if only the right people took the right actions. In reality, a socialist economy can never provide prosperity and never has. The…

READ MORE