Products – The Centre for Independent Studies

Fiscal Fiction: The Real Medicare Levy

Jeremy Sammut
07 May 2017 | RR27
Fiscal Fiction: The Real Medicare Levy

The Medicare Levy is, and always has been, a fiscal fiction. The revenue raised by the levy is not ‘hypothecated’ – dedicated specifically to fund Medicare – but goes into general government revenue. Moreover, the amount of revenue raised by the levy accounts for a mere fraction of government spending on health.  Nevertheless, the levy – by fostering the myth that Medicare costs taxpayers only a small percentage of their incomes – creates the false impression that Medicare is a low cost and affordable government program.

This report sets the record straight by telling the truth about the Medicare Levy. The details provided here about the ‘real’ Medicare levy – the actual proportions and rate of income tax that funds Medicare entitlements and other health-related government expenditure – deserves to be well known by the hard-working taxpayers of Australia.  A better understanding of the true cost of health to taxpayers is essential in order to have an informed and honest debate about any plan to hike taxes by further increasing the Medicare Levy. The alternative approach recommended here is to seeking efficiencies in health spending by undertaking reforms that can produce substantial savings and be used for other purposes such as funding the NDIS.

Buy Hardcopy
Latest Publications

Beating lockdown blues: Students pass the Covid test
Glenn Fahey
25 October 2021 | RR42

Students have suffered educational disruption in combatting the spread of covid-19. Education policy and practice during the pandemic has faced uncertainty, with some a priori assumptions proven true, while others not. The research tests the following a priori assumptions of home-based learning against the evidence that is now available: Disadvantaged students will suffer educationally from a digital divide. Students will…

READ MORE
Mind the Gap: Understanding the Indigenous education gap and how to close it
Glenn Fahey
24 June 2021 | RR41

Indigenous educational disadvantage remains among the most pressing and persistent public policy challenges in Australia. Despite bipartisan and intergovernmental commitment to ‘Closing the Gap’, has done little to move the needle in education outcomes. Dispiritingly poor education outcomes persist despite the best of intentions, considerable investment of resources, and countless programmes and initiatives of policymakers. This research examines sources and…

READ MORE
Dollars and Sense: Time for smart reform of Australian school funding
Glenn Fahey
01 December 2020 | RR40

Australia is among the world’s highest-spending countries on schooling. Yet, the educational return on this investment for parents, taxpayers, employers, and students, has deteriorated — despite the expectation of policymakers that increased funding would inevitably improve educational outcomes. It’s true that money matters when it comes to schooling, but how money is used is what really matters, not how much…

READ MORE
Overcoming the Odds: A study of Australia’s top-performing disadvantaged schools
Blaise Joseph
18 March 2019 | RR39

Students from disadvantaged social backgrounds perform worse on average academically than more advantaged students. This study investigated Australia’s top-performing disadvantaged schools in terms of literacy and numeracy results, with the aim of finding any common policies and practices which have led to their success. Nine top-performing disadvantaged schools were visited by a researcher for this study, involving interviews with school…

READ MORE
Dying with Their Rights On: The myths and realities of ending homelessness in Australia
Carlos d'Abrera
12 December 2018 | RR38

The orthodox understanding of the causes of homelessness promoted by the ‘homelessness industry’ over emphasises the role of economic and social structures. Solutions based on structuralist explanations – such as increasing the supply of affordable social housing – are insufficient to reduce rough sleeping. Such approaches minimise the need to address assertively, the individual characteristics, choices, and behaviours of rough…

READ MORE