The case against tax increases in Australia: The growing burden

Michael Potter
07 June 2016 | Research Report 15
The case against tax increases in Australia: The growing burden

View Interactive Snapshot

The tax burden imposed by the Commonwealth Government alone, and by all Australian governments, is above its historical levels and forecast to go well above these averages. Similar results are obtained if the budget deficit is included to measure the long-run tax burden. In the past when the budget was close to balance, the tax burden was slightly lower than today and spending was much lower. When the tax burden rose above average, governments took significant decisions to alleviate the burden, not stand by and allow it to increase. Previous major policies to increase the tax burden have been abandoned.

Tax hikes because of tax avoidance would have the largest impact on businesses who pay the most tax and leave the largest tax avoiders unaffected, while actually exacerbating the incentives for avoidance.

The structural budget balance shows that the current budget balance and (probably) tax levels are due to government decisions not the state of the economy. Revenue writedowns have major problems: this measure reflects forecasting errors more than anything else and deferring to this measure would lead to large tax increases in recessions.

Australia cannot be said to be a low taxing country as IMF and World Bank data says our overall tax level is above the developed world average, while our personal and company tax levels are substantially above international averages.

Based on this analysis, Australia does not have a tax revenue problem.

Buy Hardcopy
Latest Publications

Fairer Paid Parental Leave
Matthew Taylor
07 July 2014 | T30.11

Australia spends just under $1.4 billion (2012–13) on statutory Paid Parental Leave (PPL) to provide more than 130,000 parents with up to 18 weeks of parental leave paid at the full-time minimum wage. The Abbott government proposes to pay primary carers at their pre-birth wages up to a cap of $100,000 for up to 26 weeks. This policy would dramatically…

Withholding Dividends: Better ways to make the public sector efficient
Alexander Philipatos
29 May 2014 | T30.10

As the commission of audit has uncovered, the government must make significant cuts to spending to get the budget back into surplus. In the quest to find savings, the government cannot ignore the public service. For almost 25 years the government has turned to the efficiency dividend to find budget savings and improve efficiency in the public service. But the…

School Funding on a Budget
Jennifer Buckingham
30 April 2014 | T30.09

Government expenditure on schools has more than doubled in real terms in the last 25 years, while student numbers have only grown by 18%. Funding for school education was 3.1% of GDP in 2012–13, and is projected to reach 3.4% by 2025 under current predictions of economic growth. Large increases in real per-student expenditure have not been accompanied by improved…

Submission to the National Commission of Audit
Alexander Philipatos, Jennifer Buckingham, Jeremy Sammut, Robert Carling, Simon Cowan, Stephen Kirchner, Trisha Jha
01 April 2014 | T30.08

The federal government’s Commission of Audit (CoA) was established in 2013 to review the performance and role of government. This publication is an edited version of the CIS submission to the CoA listing practical solutions aimed at cutting government expenditure. The government should adopt a dual approach to its review of spending. First, spending cuts can save the federal government…

States of Debt
Robert Carling
20 March 2014 | T30.07

While Commonwealth government debt has been the focus of attention recently, this report takes a broader view by bringing state debt into the picture. State debt, like that of the federal government, has also risen dramatically since 2007, when net debt was negative. In the six years to 2013, states added $70 billion to their general government net debt, to…