Products – The Centre for Independent Studies

What are Low Ability Workers To Do When Unskilled Jobs Disappear? Part 2

Peter Saunders
14 February 2008 | IA93
What are Low Ability Workers To Do When Unskilled Jobs Disappear? Part 2

Part 2: Expanding Low-skilled Employment

  • One reason working-age welfare dependency remains high is that the demand for unskilled labour is in decline. Part 1 of this CIS Issue Analysis showed that more education and training will be of limited help to jobless people who do not have the ability to perform highly skilled tasks. What they need is an expansion in the number of lower-skilled jobs for them to do.
  • No single policy can expand low-skilled employment. Simultaneous action is needed on four fronts: (1) reducing the cost of unskilled labour to employers, (2) making employment more attractive than welfare, (3) boosting new personal service employment, and (4) improving people’s social skills and competences.
  • Cutting minimum wages best reduces the cost of unskilled labour. Australia has the second‑highest minimum wage in the OECD, yet our tax and benefits systems mean our lowest-paid workers take home less than in some countries with a lower minimum wage. A 20% reduction in our minimum wage could generate another 100,000 jobs but would still leave our minimum wage comparable with that of countries such as New Zealand and the UK, and tax changes could compensate workers for the cut. No household should pay tax until its earnings exceed the welfare minimum.
  • Further reforms to welfare benefits are needed to discourage dependency. While some welfare groups want to weaken or abandon work requirements for disadvantaged jobseekers, the opposite is necessary: work requirements should be extended to more categories of welfare recipients.
  • This entails changing Parenting Payment eligibility rules, applying new capacity criteria to existing DSP claimants, ending unemployment benefits for school leavers, and replacing the first six months of unemployment benefits with drawings from personal savings accounts.
  • The main area of potential employment growth for low-skilled workers is in personal services, for these jobs are not easily automated or exported. If minimum wages fell, service employment would expand. The paper explores the potential for increased employment in home-based services for the elderly, child care for working parents, mentoring for children in poorer neighbourhoods, and other community-based services.
  • Personal services employment requires ‘social skills’ such as reliability, honesty, politeness, and a smart appearance. Lack of these qualities (rather than any lack of technical or vocational skills) may prove the biggest obstacle to people on welfare finding employment, particularly young males. Schools have a key role in raising social skills, and conditional welfare is important to reinforce shared norms. School leavers who cannot find work or training should be offered a place in the military or in a new Peace Corps that could also help inculcate a stronger sense of social responsibility.

Professor Peter Saunders is the Social Research Director of The Centre for Independent Studies, and the author of Australia’s Welfare Habit, and How to Kick It.

Latest Publications

Eight Housing Affordability Myths
Stephen Kirchner
10 July 2014 | IA146

Australians are conflicted in their attitude to this long-run change in real house prices because they are both investors in housing as an asset class and consumers of housing services. This conflicted attitude on the part of the public is reflected in confused public policies followed by Australian governments. Unfortunately, many of the policies pursued by Australian governments in the…

Still Damaging and Disturbing: Australian Child Protection Data and the Need for National Adoption Targets
Jeremy Sammut
16 April 2014 | IA145

In December 2013, the Abbott government announced plans to make it easier for Australian parents to adopt children both locally and from overseas. Acknowledging the official ‘taboo’ on adoption in Australia, Prime Minister Tony Abbott ordered an inter-departmental committee to recommend ways to take adoption out of the ‘too-hard’ basket. The chief barrier to raising the number of local adoptions…

Why Jaydon Can’t Read: A Forum on Fixing Literacy
Jennifer Buckingham, Justine Ferrari, Tom Alegounarias
18 February 2014 | IA144

Many thousands of Australian students have very low levels of literacy after spending four or more years at school. The Spring 2014 issue of the CIS journal Policy contained an article called ‘Why Jaydon Can’t Read: How Ideology Triumphed Over Evidence in Teaching Reading’, which concluded that students were not being provided with the most effective evidence-based reading instruction in…

Independent Charities, Independent Regulators: The Future of Not-for-Profit Regulation
Helen Andrews
06 February 2014 | IA143

The Australian Charities and Not-for-Profits Commission was established by the Gillard government in 2012 with the intended purpose of cutting the red tape faced by Australia’s charities. So far, the regulator has failed to make any significant progress on this goal or on its two other main goals: increasing public trust in charities and improving the quality of regulatory oversight…

The New Silence: Family Breakdown and Child Sexual Abuse
Jeremy Sammut
30 January 2014 | IA142

Despite family breakdown exposing children to greater risk of sexual abuse, the issue receives scant attention in this country. Child sexual abuse is not fully and frankly discussed because the public discourse is self-censored by politicians, academics, social service organisations, and the media in compliance with politically correct attitudes towards ‘family diversity’—the socially ‘progressive’ and ‘non-judgmental’ fiction that says the…